David Chadwick Leads Westminster Debate on Threat to Community Hospitals
Welsh Liberal Democrat MP for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe David Chadwick has led a debate in Westminster on the threat to community hospitals, urging the Welsh Government to think again over plans that could cut the number of physical health inpatient beds in Powys from 148 to just 60.
Under both options put forward by Powys Teaching Health Board, Ystradgynlais, Welshpool, Llanidloes, Machynlleth and Bronllys would lose their inpatient beds. Llandrindod Wells would also lose its beds under the 60-bed option, while the mothballed beds in Knighton would stay closed.
The proposals would also close two minor injuries units in Ystradgynlais and Welshpool, remove X-ray services from several sites and concentrate inpatient mental health care on a single site.
More than 10,000 people have signed a petition opposing the cuts, and every GP surgery in Powys has signed a letter raising concerns. Thousands of residents have attended public meetings across the constituency. In Ystradgynlais, the meeting was so full that people stood outside in the street to listen.
Chadwick spoke at rallies in the last fortnight in Llandrindod Wells and Ystradgynlais. Whilst, campaigners in Welshpool pushed a hospital bed through the town centre in a protest organised by Richard Church & Carol Robinson.
Powys has no district general hospital of its own, and many residents rely on community hospitals to recover closer to family after treatment in Hereford, Shrewsbury or Swansea. In the health board’s own evaluation of its step-down and rehabilitation units, most families reported having less far to travel to visit, while patients valued the support they received from physiotherapists.
Chadwick warned that reducing step-down beds could leave patients who are ready to leave an acute ward stuck in hospital further from home, leaving fewer beds for people who need acute treatment. He said closing minor injuries units could also send more patients to already stretched A&E departments and add to ambulance delays. He pointed out that many people who use community hospitals never stay overnight, including patients who need regular blood tests and rely on an infrequent bus or a lift from a neighbour.
During the debate, Chadwick cited a report by England’s Chief Medical Officer, Professor Sir Chris Whitty, which highlighted the role of community hospitals where larger hospitals are hard to reach. He said the health board needed to explain how it would expand district nursing and rehabilitation across rural Powys. Staff making several visits a day to patients in scattered villages could spend much of a shift on the road, and the health board had yet to explain how much extra work would fall to the council or who would pay for it.
He also criticised Welsh Government Plaid Cymru Ministers for refusing to intervene in the process.
Chadwick also paid tribute to the League of Friends groups at the various hospitals for the work they have done over decades in their local hospitals, highlighting that many of the hospitals under threat were built by the community before the NHS was even founded.
Commenting after the debate, Welsh Liberal Democrat MP for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe David Chadwick said:
“People in Powys want answers. Where will their parents recover after an operation? Where will they go for an X-ray after a fall? If someone they love needs end-of-life care, will they be close enough to visit every day?
“I want more people to be able to recover at home, but even in the unlikely case the board delivers everything it has promised for in home care, patients will still need community hospital beds, especially in large rural counties.
“The Plaid Cymru Health Minister keeps pointing to the health board, but the Welsh Government holds the purse strings. The buck-passing needs to stop. People in Powys deserve to hear directly from their Health Minister about how our community hospitals can be protected. The Minister should listen to the thousands of people who have spoken up and think again before these beds are lost.”
ENDS
Sign up
for email updates